Certain TV character deaths have an impact on us that goes beyond shock; they haunt us. We continue to remember them time and again, even after the episode is over, and each time we recall them, they bring back emotional pain. These instances hurt because they seem to be personal losses, as if we had lost a real friend. It doesn’t matter if those characters died saving others, if it was a surprising plot twist, or just a grim indication that death can come to anyone; these TV deaths shocked the audience so much that they changed the entire show. Check out 15 character deaths that fans found the most difficult to handle.
15. Joel Miller — The Last of Us
Joel Miller wasn’t just a survivor; he was the emotional backbone of The Last of Us. Watching him slowly soften through his relationship with Ellie turned a hardened man into something deeply human, and that transformation made viewers fiercely protective of him.
His violent death was deliberately brutal, denying audiences any sense of closure. It shattered expectations and forced fans to sit with discomfort, grief, and rage, mirroring Ellie’s emotional spiral. Joel’s loss didn’t just move the story forward; it permanently altered how viewers experienced the show’s world.
14. Glenn Rhee — The Walking Dead
From the very beginning, Glenn represented hope in a world falling apart. He was clever, compassionate, and endlessly loyal, making him one of The Walking Dead’s most beloved characters.
His death was shocking not just because it happened, but because of how mercilessly it unfolded. The graphic brutality stunned audiences and marked a turning point for the series, with many fans feeling that Glenn’s loss took the show’s heart with it.
13. Ashtray — Euphoria
Ashtray stood out as a tragic contradiction: a child forced into adulthood far too soon. Quiet, deadly, and fiercely loyal to Fezco, he became one of Euphoria’s most compelling characters despite his limited screen time.
His final moments were chaotic and devastating, ending in a way that felt both sudden and tragically inevitable. Ashtray’s death underscored the show’s harsh message, that innocence doesn’t survive long in a world built on violence, and fans were left heartbroken by how little chance he ever had.
12. Sean Devlin — Derry Girls
Derry Girls is known for its humor, which made Sean Devlin’s death hit even harder. The show rarely leaned into tragedy, so when it did, it felt startlingly real.
Handled with restraint and respect, Sean’s passing served as a sobering reminder of the political tensions surrounding the characters’ lives. It grounded the comedy in reality and left a quiet emotional scar that lingered through the rest of the series.
11. Lady — Game of Thrones
Lady’s death was one of the earliest warnings that Game of Thrones would not play fair. As Sansa Stark’s gentle direwolf, Lady, symbolized innocence and safety, the show was quick to strip away.
Her execution felt cruel and undeserved, making it all the more painful to watch. For many fans, it was the moment they realized no character, human or otherwise, was safe in this world.
10. Sarah Lynn — BoJack Horseman
Sarah Lynn’s life was a tragedy long before it ended. Once a child star, she spiraled under fame, addiction, and neglect, with BoJack Horseman chronicling her pain in devastating detail.
Her death wasn’t played for shock; it was slow, uncomfortable, and haunting. The aftermath forced viewers to confront the consequences of selfishness and systemic failure, making her loss one of the most emotionally exhausting moments in animated television.
9. Boo — Fleabag
Boo’s presence looms over Fleabag even though she’s already gone when the show begins. Through flashbacks, viewers slowly piece together who she was and why her absence hurts so deeply.
The truth behind Boo’s death is quietly devastating, rooted in guilt and misunderstanding. Her loss shapes Fleabag’s grief, humor, and self-destruction, making Boo one of the most emotionally significant off-screen deaths in TV history.
8. Wallace — The Wire
Wallace represented vulnerability in a world that punished it. Young, kind-hearted, and overwhelmed by guilt, he struggled to survive in Baltimore’s unforgiving streets.
His death was chilling because of its inevitability. Killed by people he trusted, Wallace’s loss became a defining moment for The Wire, perfectly capturing the show’s brutal honesty about systemic violence and lost innocence.
7. Mona Simpson — The Simpsons
Mona Simpson brought unexpected emotional depth to The Simpsons. Her strained relationship with Homer revealed a side of him rarely seen: vulnerable, abandoned, and desperate for connection.
Her death episode balanced humor with genuine sorrow, culminating in one of the show’s most touching endings. Mona’s passing reminded audiences that even long-running comedies can deliver moments of real emotional weight.
6. Hodor — Game of Thrones
Hodor’s death was one of Game of Thrones’ most powerful twists. A character known almost entirely for kindness and loyalty was revealed to have lived a life shaped by tragedy from the very start.
His final act, holding the door, was both heroic and horrifying, revealing that his entire existence had been leading to this moment. Fans mourned Hodor not just for his death, but for the life he never truly got to live.
5. Bobby Singer — Supernatural
Bobby Singer was more than a hunter; he was family. Acting as a surrogate father to Sam and Dean, Bobby provided stability, tough love, and moral grounding throughout Supernatural.
His death felt deeply unfair, stripping the brothers of their emotional anchor. Even after he was gone, Bobby’s influence lingered, and fans continued to feel his absence for the rest of the series.
4. Marvin Eriksen Sr. — How I Met Your Mother
Marvin Eriksen Sr.’s death blindsided viewers just as it blindsided Marshall. What began as a lighthearted episode suddenly turned into one of the most raw portrayals of grief in sitcom history.
The show handled the moment with honesty and restraint, allowing silence and emotion to do the heavy lifting. For many fans, it was painfully relatable and impossible to forget.
3. Seymour — Futurama
Few TV moments have traumatized audiences like Seymour’s story in Futurama. Fry’s dog, waiting endlessly for his owner’s return, became a universal symbol of loyalty and loss.
The episode’s final montage shattered viewers, proving that animation could be just as emotionally devastating as live-action drama. Seymour’s story remains one of the saddest narratives ever told on television.
2. Ben Sullivan — Scrubs
Ben Sullivan’s death stands as one of Scrubs’ most masterfully executed emotional twists. Brendan Fraser’s warmth made Ben instantly lovable, especially through his bond with Dr. Cox.
The reveal of his death recontextualized the entire episode, delivering an emotional gut punch that fans still talk about years later. It perfectly showcased Scrubs’ ability to balance humor with profound sadness.
1. Tara Maclay — Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Tara Maclay’s death was sudden, shocking, and deeply upsetting. As a source of gentleness and stability, she represented safety in a show built on chaos.
Her loss shattered both the characters and the audience, triggering one of the darkest arcs in Buffy’s history. Tara’s death remains one of television’s most controversial and emotionally impactful moments, symbolizing how deeply fans connect to characters who feel real.
Great TV deaths hurt because they mean something. They aren’t just plot devices, they’re emotional landmarks that define characters, reshape stories, and stay with viewers long after the screen fades to black. These losses remind us why television can be so powerful: when it’s done right, fictional grief feels real, and sometimes, heartbreak is exactly what makes a story unforgettable.