Wonder Woman is not simply another superhero—she’s a cultural icon. For years, Gal Gadot was Diana Prince, but with her departure from the role, fans are abuzz about who might next take up the mantle. James Gunn’s DCU is remaking the playbook, and casting the new Wonder Woman will be one of its most iconic decisions. So who’s got the strength, charisma, and heart to fill those legendary shoes? Let’s count down 10 of the top contenders—beginning with long shots and finishing with a bold surprise.
10. May Calamawy – Marvel Star Willing to Switch Sides
Fans adored May Calamawy as Layla in Moon Knight, but her Marvel prospects are unclear. It hasn’t dissuaded folks from dreaming up her as Diana Prince—and she’s stated that she would even be interested. With action credentials, her charismatic screen presence, and Egyptian-Palestinian heritage, Calamawy might infuse Wonder Woman with something new and vibrant.
9. Melissa Barrera – Horror Heroine with Heart
From Scream to Abigail, Melissa Barrera has shown that she can lead a franchise and bring grit and vulnerability to the screen. She’s also spoken about what the role means, saying how much it means to get into Wonder Woman’s spirit. With her strength and likability, Barrera might bring a grounded yet inspiring interpretation of Diana.
8. Katy O’Brien – An Actual Warrior in the Making
If you desire a Wonder Woman who actually appears to be capable of commanding an army, Katy O’Brien is your woman. A bodybuilder and martial artist who possesses serious dramatic talent (Love Lies Bleeding was proof positive), she has just the right mix of brute strength and emotional resonance. She’s already appeared in The Mandalorian and Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania—so superhero experience is nothing new for her.
7. Jessica Green – Fan-Favorite with Amazonian Energy
Jessica Green might not be a household name yet, but fans can’t stop pointing to her as a natural fit for Wonder Woman. Known for The Outpost, she has the height, the combat training, and the look that screams Diana Prince. Green’s fresh energy could be exactly what the DCU needs for its reboot.
6. Alexandra Daddario – Longtime Fan Pick
Alexandra Daddario has long been fancast as Wonder Woman, and it would be an easy victory for her. She’s already voiced Lois Lane in DC animation, proving she gets the essence of these characters. With genre experience under her belt and a strong presence, Daddario would be a shoo-in for the part fans have longed to see her play.
5. Ana de Armas – Hollywood’s Action Powerhouse
Few actresses match Ana de Armas’ star power, physicality, and emotional range. Whether in No Time to Die or Ballerina, she’s proved she can bring grace and ruthlessness in equal amounts. De Armas would add a new layer of vulnerability to Wonder Woman without losing the edge that makes Diana so legendary.
4. Laura Harrier – Poised and Powerful
Laura Harrier already got her feet wet in the superhero arena with Spider-Man: Homecoming, but she’s primed for a starring role. Standing at 5’9″, with a commanding screen presence in films like BlacKkKlansman, she has both the physical and emotional depth to bring Diana to life. Harrier might walk that fine line between regal and relatable.
3. Emma Mackey – Talent on the Rise with DCU Connections
Emma Mackey has previously appeared on casting lists, even testing for Lois Lane, reportedly. She’s already shown her range in Sex Education and Barbie, and ironically enough, she co-starred with Gal Gadot in Death on the Nile. That association alone makes her an elegiac choice to take on the Wonder Woman mantle, introducing a youthful energy and new vision to the character.
2. Adria Arjona – The Fan (and Gunn) Favorite
Adria Arjona’s name continues to resurface for a reason. She’s great in anything from Andor to Hit Man, and she’s got a track record with James Gunn, who once opined she’d be “great” as Wonder Woman. Arjona herself has embraced the fan casting, and her talent, presence, and DCU background make her one of the leading contenders.
1. The Nubia Possibility – Growing the Wonder Woman Legacy
This is where things get truly fascinating: rather than simply recasting Diana, Gunn’s DCU can bring in Nubia, a comic book character who also bore the Wonder Woman mantle. Nubia is frequently characterized as Diana’s rival or sister, and she has even taken over as ruler of Themyscira in some narratives. Bringing her in would not only pay respect to comic book tradition but also provide viewers with two Wonder Women, setting the stage for deeper storytelling and representation.
Regardless of who wields the Lasso of Truth next, rest assured that the future of the DCU will be determined by the next Wonder Woman. Whether it’s a new up-and-comer, a beloved veteran, or even something new and crazy like Nubia, Diana’s legacy will only keep growing. And that’s why this casting is one of the most thrilling—and significant—moves DC has ever made.