So, you just finished binge-watching your Untamed marathon on Netflix, and now the post-show blues are coming for you. Don’t fret—you’re not alone here. When a narrative is full of intrigue, suspense, and characters that linger in your mind, the need for “just one more like that” is very real. The good news? Several other shows are waiting to scratch that same itch. I compiled a countdown of the most engrossing crime mysteries you can sink your teeth into next—programs specifically teeming with brooding detectives, menacing villains, and secrets you’ll be desperate to reveal. Take a snack (or a magnifying glass) and let’s get down to the best ones.
10. Barry
A hitman with a secret dream of becoming an actor—what’s the worst that could happen? Bill Hader stars in this darkly comedic series about a murderer attempting to rewrite his narrative through community theater. The combination of absurdist humor and hard-punch drama makes Barry an unparalleled binge. If you enjoyed the emotional complexity of Untamed, Barry’s complex path will draw you in. Available to stream on HBO Max.
9. Bates Motel
Think you know Norman Bates? This prequel explores the dysfunctional teenage years of the Psycho legend. Freddie Highmore’s unnerving performance as Norman, combined with Vera Farmiga’s eerie depiction of his mom, makes the show a twisted family drama alongside a thriller. The secrets in this one are weighty—and unforgettable. Stream it on Prime Video.
8. Killing Eve
Elegant, sassy, and hyper-addictive—Killing Eve offers you a detective vs. assassin with a flirtation twist. Sandra Oh is a tired investigator pursuing Jodie Comer’s lovely, loose-cannon killer through Europe. Their chemistry is charged, the humor wicked, and the tension perpetual. See it for free on Tubi.
7. Hannibal
This isn’t your average crime show—it’s a visual treat seasoned with psychological terror. Chilling elegance is brought to Hannibal Lecter by Mads Mikkelsen, and Hugh Dancy plays Will Graham, the profiler seduced by his world. Their dynamic is tense, brilliant, and completely haunting. If you need a show that sticks with you, this is the one. Stream it on Prime Video.
6. Criminal Minds
Serial killers, gruesome puzzles, and one indelible FBI team. Criminal Minds offsets bleak, sensationalized cases with an endearing ensemble cast that makes the show strangely cozy. From Spencer Reid’s brilliant idiosyncrasies to Garcia’s offbeat genius, the characters are the show’s soul. Catch it on Paramount+.
5. True Detective
Every season presents a new tale, but each of them delves deep into mystery and personal demons. Season one with Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson is iconic TV. Dark, philosophical, and full of creepy twists—this show is ideal if you’re craving mystery infused with meaning. Stream it on HBO Max and Hulu.
4. Mindhunter
Step back into the 1970s and see the FBI try to find out how to read serial killers. Jonathan Groff and Holt McCallany are agents who are interviewing actual criminals in order to create psychological profiles. It’s creepy, clinical, and fascinating—like seeing history and horror intersect. Streaming on Netflix.
3. Dark Winds
This sleeper of a hit differentiates itself with its Navajo Nation of the 1970s backdrop. Tracking tribal police officers Joe Leaphorn and Jim Chee, Dark Winds blends thrilling mysteries and cultural complexity. The sweeping desert landscape provides an unsettling, atmospheric tension that Untamed fans will enjoy. Stream it on Netflix or AMC+.
2. Broadchurch
A coastal town rocked by tragedy. Detectives Alec Hardy (David Tennant) and Ellie Miller (Olivia Colman) strip away layers of sadness, deceptions, and betrayal following the murder of a young boy. The acting is superb, the pacing just right, and the tension unending. Stream it on Prime Video.
1. The Sinner
Right at the top of this list is this ingenious take on the crime genre. Rather than “whodunit,” The Sinner wants to know, “why did they do it?” Bill Pullman plays Detective Harry Ambrose, solving horrifying crimes carried out by ordinary-looking individuals. Each season is a standalone, intense thriller, full of psychological complexity. There are four ready for you on Netflix.
And there you go—your next line of must-watch crime shows. If you’re a fan of psychological thrillers, small-town mysteries, or quirky detectives, these shows will have you up too late at night muttering, “just one more episode.”