If you’re the kind of person who enjoys puzzle-solving, lives on plot twists, or simply likes to scream “I knew it!” at the television, Prime Video’s got you covered. The service is filled with mysteries and thrillers that’ll challenge your detective work and keep you on edge until the last twist. From courtroom dramas to psychological thrillers and contemporary whodunits, there’s a little bit of everything here for every type of sleuth. Here are 10 of the top mystery films currently streaming—descending from the latest gem to the all-time favorites.
10. Murder & Cocktails (2024)
Who says murder can’t be chic? This lighthearted whodunit turns suburban suspense on its head. When a neighbor is found dead, Nick and Lana host cocktail gatherings to figure out the killer. Each guest is suspect, each cocktail is a hint, and the tension builds with each shaken martini. It’s Agatha Christie goes to happy hour—flair, flashy, and full of tension.
9. Above Suspicion (2019)
Based on a true case, this gritty thriller delves into the life-threatening romance between an FBI newcomer and his informant in rural Appalachia. It’s ragged, suspenseful, and a chilling reminder that blurred lines between duty and passion can kill quickly. If you prefer your mysteries based on actual crime, this is the one.
8. Beyond a Reasonable Doubt (2009)
In this remake of the 1956 film, a reporter sets himself up for murder to catch a crooked district attorney, but when the scheme goes awry, clearing his own name is the ultimate test. Full of snap turns and hairpin tension, it’s the type of picture that will make you suspect the motives of every character.
7. Old (2021)
Leave it to M. Night Shyamalan to make a beach vacation into a nightmare. A family finds a hidden beach where time accelerates, and they’re aged decades in just one day. The only escape? Unravel the secret of the beach before their lives are gone. Creepy, unsettling, and full of twists—this one will haunt you.
6. Jagged Edge (1985)
Glenn Close excels as a defense attorney for a man who stands accused of killing his wife—but the more she investigates, the more sordid it becomes. Is she defending a wrongly accused man or assisting a murderer? A mix of courtroom thriller and psychological suspense, this 80s thriller still delivers.
5. The Bone Collector (1999)
Denzel Washington stars as a paralyzed detective, partnered with rookie cop Angelina Jolie, who set out to capture a painstaking serial killer who leaves cryptic clues. Clever, suspenseful, and brain-twisting, it’s a thrilling cat-and-mouse game that you’ll be solving alongside the leads.
4. Absence of Malice (1981)
When a businessman is unfairly linked to a murder by an enterprising reporter, the consequences reveal the thin line between aggressive reporting and sensationalized storytelling. Paul Newman and Sally Field star in this biting, intelligent drama that posits: what happens when the truth is just another tool?
3. Wind River (2017)
Set on an isolated Native American reservation, this chilling murder mystery tracks a tracker (Jeremy Renner) and an FBI agent (Elizabeth Olsen) as they expose sinister secrets after a young woman is killed. Stark, emotional, and handsomely photographed, it’s both a thrilling crime drama and a powerful commentary on abandoned communities.
2. Charade (1963)
Charm and wit are supplied by Audrey Hepburn and Cary Grant to this combination of mystery, romance, and comedy. When Hepburn’s character discovers that her husband has been murdered, she’s pulled into a perilous search for pilfered cash—with a lot of twists and quick wit for dialogue along the way. It’s glamorous, intelligent, and constantly re-watchable.
1. The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
Few mysteries are quite so iconic as this one. Jodie Foster’s first-time FBI agent goes to the diabolical but genius Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins) to capture the gruesome Buffalo Bill. Creepy atmosphere, unforgettable performances, and suspense that never abates—this is not only a mystery, it’s a masterpiece.
Prime Video’s mystery lineup proves that not all great nights need a comedy or rom-com. Whether you’re into stylish whodunits, tense crime dramas, or psychological thrillers, these 10 films will keep your brain racing and your pulse pounding. So dim the lights, pour yourself a drink, and see if you can crack the case before the credits roll.