Sometimes, a single character can be the reason that a great TV show loses its shine and falls apart. You’ve definitely come across that kind of person—someone who makes you groan every time they show up, take over the story when you didn’t ask, or kill the vibe of the situation with their humorless approach. Maybe they were lovable at the start, or maybe they were a disaster from their very first sentence. In any case, they’ve turned your regular watching into a stamina challenge. Here’s a look at ten TV characters whose fans say were the main reasons their shows got ruined—one irritating plot twist at a time.
10. Emily Cooper (Emily in Paris)
Emily twirls through Paris in designer clothes and boundless cheer, but her complete cluelessness regarding French culture has pushed more than a few fans’ buttons. In some way, she manages to fail up instead of down, winning every break without actually deserving it. For many fans, her “plucky expat” charm wore thin quickly.
9. Nate Shelley (Ted Lasso)
Nate’s journey from awkward kit man to full-fledged petty villain was on paper, but to some viewers, it simply weighed the show down. His heel-turn felt more like a tedious, frustrating side trip than an engaging twist—one that had many cheering for him to simply leave the pitch once and for all.
8. Beth Dutton (Yellowstone)
Beth’s cutting comebacks and boardroom fights earned her an icon status for some but were intolerable for others. Her perpetual bickering, particularly with her brother Jamie, can be draining. She’s undoubtedly a force to be reckoned with, but her excessive antics have driven many viewers from amused to annoyed.
7. Piper Chapman (Orange Is the New Black)
She’s the star, but Piper soon proved to be the least interesting inmate in Litchfield. With her selfish decisions, playing the victim, and constant drama, she was overshadowed by the rich, multilayered supporting cast. Fans admit they stuck around despite her, not because of her.
6. Xander Harris (Buffy the Vampire Slayer)
The so-called “lovable everyman” soon wore out his welcome with sexist humor and refusal to own up. Some viewers felt his attitude brought down the group dynamic—and wondered why the rest of the Scooby Gang put up with him to begin with.
5. Rory Gilmore (Gilmore Girls)
Book-smart, nice, and easy to support, early Rory. College Rory? Entitled, irresponsible, and infuriatingly well-liked by all those in her orbit, even with a string of selfish choices. Even loyal fans have admitted their re-watches are accompanied by a side of eye-rolling whenever she appears on screen.
4. Debbie Gallagher (Shameless)
Debbie’s transition from bad girl to manipulative woman had viewers tired. Her decisions tended to do more harm than good, and instead of maturing, she doubled down on bad behavior—making her one of the show’s most divisive characters.
3. Skyler White (Breaking Bad)
Few television characters have polarized audiences as much as Skyler. Some empathized with her situation, but others enjoyed her so much that they couldn’t get through the first season. For part of the fan base, she was the biggest obstacle to liking the show.
2. Lana Lang (Smallville)
Lana was supposed to be Clark’s great love, but her incessant indecision and melodrama became a burden to bear. The fans wanted the show to get past her, and so she became one of TV’s biggest overstayed welcomes.
1. Dana (Mythic Quest)
Dana is at the top of this list due to her self-appointed hobby of policing everyone else’s hobbies and bulldozing boundaries. Her habitual moral posturing wore on enough people that some of them stopped watching altogether. She’s the epitome of a “can’t watch this anymore” character.
Love them, hate them, or love to hate them—these characters show one thing: TV drama doesn’t just exist on the page. Sometimes, the most fierce arguments occur off-camera, between fans arguing over who messed up what.