If there is a power that is above the typical creepy lights and making 80s songs popular again, then it is tearing down our hearts. Throughout these four seasons, we have seen characters that we love (and some nice surprises) dying in such a way that we still think about them long after the credits dance. From deaths that were so brief that you couldn’t see them to farewells that hit you right in the stomach, here is a list ranking deaths in Hawkins that have made people cry the most.
10. The Nameless Many
Before we discuss the A-listers, a shout-out to background heroes—and victims. Hawkins Lab workers, Russian scientists, miscellaneous neighbors… the Upside Down doesn’t discriminate. Whether it’s the Demogorgon ripping through lab technicians, the Mind Flayer taking whole rooms of souls, or Vecna’s body count at the NINA project, these anonymous tragedies establish the tone: in Hawkins, no one is safe.
9. Chrissy Cunningham
Chrissy’s season 4 demise was a tonal hammer. She was a cliché mean girl at first, but some quiet moments revealed that she was troubled—and then Vecna happened. Her bloody death in Eddie’s trailer shocked us, but it also served to announce that this season would be darker than ever before.
8. Mews the Cat
Laugh all you want, but Dustin losing his family cat was downright cruel. Mews had become food for Dart the Demodog in season 2, and Dustin’s embarrassing lie to his mom only made things worse. Tiny moment? Yes, emotionally devastating for animal lovers everywhere. Absolutely.
7. Dr. Martin Brenner (“Papa”)
The guy who experimented on Eleven isn’t a sympathetic candidate, but his season 4 departure was complicated. Brenner’s final moments made Eleven—and us—struggle with all those years of manipulation, abuse, and warped affection. It’s not an easy “good riddance,” which makes it more impactful.
6. Billy Hargrove
Billy began as the resident bad boy bully on the show, but by season 3’s conclusion, he’d earned some redemption. Possessed by the Mind Flayer, he eventually gave his life protecting Eleven and the others. Seeing Max lose it over his death was as painful as his last act of heroism.
5. Barb Holland
Barb’s death may not have been the most sensational, but it’s quite possibly one of the most discussed. She was merely in the wrong place at the wrong moment, consumed by the Demogorgon as Nancy danced the night away upstairs. The absence of in-show justice only added to the fan outrage—Justice for Barb was a cause for a reason.
4. Alexei
It really wasn’t on our cards to fall for a Russian scientist who was crazy for Slurpees, but Alexei did it in no time. His wit and warmth were a big part of the third season, which, when considering the circumstances of his impromptu exit at the fair, really hit us hard. He was absolutely entitled to have a bit more time with that liberation.
3. Bob Newby
Bob Newby, superhero—and cinnamon roll through and through. Sean Astin made Bob so likable and sincere that we should have guessed he was a goner. And yet, seeing him almost make it to safety before the Demodogs brought him down was a moment that no Stranger Things fan will ever forget.
2. Eddie Munson
Season 4’s breakout legend departed like a rock god. Eddie’s guitar-shredding diversion in the Upside Down was epic and heartbreaking, topped off by his emotional farewell with Dustin. A genuine hero who at last demonstrated that he wasn’t the coward others perceived him to be, just to shatter all our hearts.
1. The Hawkins Lab Children
The season 4 flashback massacre is possibly the darkest moment of the show. Seeing Henry Creel (a.k.a. One/Vecna) kill every other child at the lab was shocking, not because of the killing itself, but because these were children who—imperfections and all—never deserved their death. This act defined Eleven’s life and cast a long shadow on everything else that came thereafter, and that made it the most haunting loss of the series.
Whether you’re still replaying “Master of Puppets” for Eddie or quietly grieving Barb, Stranger Things has taught us something: no character is too beloved to be spared. And with season 5 on the horizon, we may need to begin preparing ourselves all over again.