Let’s face it—few casting choices have created as much fan hysteria as the quest for the new Wonder Woman. Now that Gal Gadot is officially hanging up her cape, the DC Universe is looking for a new Diana Prince—and fans are playing this like the superhero equivalent of the Hunger Games. Speculation, theories, and wish lists are abounding, and everyone’s got the ideal actress for the job.
But who has the grace, strength, and screen presence to take up the lasso of truth? Going by fan buzz, industry rumors, and a dash of gut feeling, here are 10 of the most promising contenders to be the next Wonder Woman.
10. Bruna Marquezine
Bruna Marquezine could already have a foot in the DCU door—she was Jenny Kord in Blue Beetle. Though that movie didn’t set the box office ablaze, she was excellent. She also allegedly auditioned for Supergirl in The Flash. Bruna has that screen presence, intensity, and DC links to make her a darkhorse contender for Diana—particularly if DC wants to lean into known quantities going forward.
9. Charlee Fraser
You’ll recognize Charlee Fraser if you’ve watched Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga. With the face of a young Gal Gadot and the raw emotional strength that lingers, Fraser is building some serious steam in the fancasting world. Fresh-faced, yes, but with a depth and strength she could both infuse and help Wonder Woman achieve in a new generation.
8. Grace Caroline Currey
Shazam! fans already know Grace Caroline Currey from her portrayal of Mary Bromfield—better known as one of the Shazam-ily’s toughest members. She’s openly thrilled to remain a part of the DCU, even going so far as to call it “nice” to be fan-cast as Wonder Woman. She’s already demonstrated she can walk the line between vulnerability and strength, and considering DC’s track record with recasting actors in new roles, her switching from Mary Marvel to Diana Prince wouldn’t be all that far-fetched.
7. Eiza González
Eiza González is a popular choice for nearly every superhero role out there these days—and Wonder Woman is no different. She was rumored to be considered for Catwoman in The Batman, and her action skills were in top form in Fountain of Youth. She’s got the face, the attitude, and the charm to play one of the most famous roles in comics.
6. May Calamawy
Marvel enthusiasts will remember May Calamawy from Moon Knight, where she positively rocked as Layla El-Faouly. With no established future in the MCU, DC can (and should) poach her. Calamawy has humor, grit, and a down-to-earth presence that would beautifully be brought to bear on a new Wonder Woman. She could offer something new and completely genuine to the role.
5. Ana de Armas
Ana de Armas is easily the largest star on this list—and she’s shown she’s capable of both action (Ballerina) and emotion (Blonde) in equal proportions. Her casting would be a huge coup for DC, instantaneously enhancing visibility and raising high expectations for the reimagined character. She’s got the talent, the presence, and the intensity to revive Wonder Woman with style and substance.
4. Monica Barbaro
Fresh from an Oscar-nominated turn in A Complete Unknown and a standout supporting role in Top Gun: Maverick, Monica Barbaro is on top of the world. She’s got undeniable star presence, an expanding resume, and the type of subtle power that might reshape Wonder Woman for the next generation. Given the right script and direction, she could command the role.
3. Melissa Barrera
Best known for spearheading the recent Scream resurgence, Melissa Barrera might bring a darker, edgier atmosphere to Wonder Woman—particularly if DC taps the “Absolute Wonder Woman” comics in which Diana grows up in hell. Barrera’s horror background demonstrates that she is not cowed by intensity, and has the dramatic chops to infuse the character with something new and bold.
2. Alexandra Daddario
Supporters have been lobbying for Alexandra Daddario as Wonder Woman for years. With her background bringing Lois Lane to life in DC’s animated series and Annabeth Chase in Percy Jackson, she’s no amateur to powerful, mythological characters. Daddario possesses fierce presence and quiet sympathy—two qualities that are necessary to make a lasting Diana Prince.
1. Adria Arjona
Adria Arjona is the name on everyone’s lips these days. From Andor to Morbius to the screamingly underappreciated Hit Man, she’s amassed a resume packed with strength, depth, and warmth. She’s even professed her desire to play Wonder Woman, telling fans to “write about it… help me,” at a recent premiere. Even James Gunn himself weighed in, admitting she’d be perfect for the role. With increasing fan backing and industry buzz, Arjona is becoming increasingly like a leader in the running.
So… Who’s Got What It Takes?
Casting Wonder Woman isn’t only about talent—it’s about being able to take over a room (or battlefield) with presence. Fans have been passionately arguing whether height is important (some want their Diana 5’9″ and taller), but ultimately, it’s about who can play the Amazonian warrior on screen. Charisma, strength, vulnerability—that elusive combination is difficult to find, but each of these actresses brings something special to the table.
James Gunn has confirmed that a new Wonder Woman movie is in the works, with Ana Nogueira to pen the script. There has been no announcement of a director, and Gunn asserts that nothing will get going until the story is set. Gal Gadot is officially off, and though Arjona sits at the heart of online rumors, no casting is confirmed. Until then, the fan wars continue. Each like, comment, and follow adds fuel to the flames. Whether your ideal Diana is an up-and-coming star, a superhero alumna, or an Oscar-nominated powerhouse, one thing is certain: whoever wins the role will enter a legacy—and the whole world will be watching.