Let’s get real: true-crime shows are like chips—you can’t have just one. They’re full of wild twists, deep dives into evil people, and the thrill of solving puzzles yourself. So, if you’re ready to trade sleep for intense moments, here are 15 top true-crime shows to get lost in. Let’s start with “really good” and end with “must-watch.”
15. The Ripper
Set in tough, 1970s Yorkshire, this brief series dives into the frightful times the Yorkshire Ripper created. It features cool, old-time scenes, great acting, and a deep impact. Critics on Rotten Tomatoes say it offers a vivid portrayal of a chilling story—and they’re right.
14. The Innocent Man
Based on John Grisham’s only true crime book, this Oklahoma series looks at two murders and uncovers huge flaws in the justice system. It’s smooth, engaging, and thoughtful—Rotten Tomatoes reviewers recommend it for any true-crime fan.
13. Evil Genius
A bank robbery, a pizza delivery woman, and a bomb around a neck? This bizarre true story is packed with strange people and shocking twists. It’s chaotic, wild, and gripping—Rotten Tomatoes suggests it’s full of surprises.
12. Tiger King
Seen the memes? Got it. Large cats and huge egos? Check. Tiger King is pure madness, and it draws you in. Rotten Tomatoes mentions its strange, almost comedic story that feels real.
11. The Pharmacist
After his son dies from drugs, one man, a pharmacist, fights to expose the dark truth behind the opioid crisis. This deep, personal series combines grief, justice, and serious errors—earning praise from critics and viewers alike.
10. McMillion$
How did a McDonald’s game become a major scam? McMillion$ unveils this real-life farce, filled with scheming and lively characters. Rotten Tomatoes appreciates its quirky but fun atmosphere.
9. Wild Wild Country
A guru, a cult, and clashes with a small town—this Oregon series is more outrageous than fiction. Rich historical footage and clever storytelling make it popular on Rotten Tomatoes for its thorough and captivating exploration.
8. The Confession Tapes
What if a confession was false? This series explores cases with coerced, confused, or untrue confessions. It’s chilling, crucial viewing—a top scorer on Rotten Tomatoes for good reason.
7. The Staircase
Did Michael Peterson kill his wife, or didn’t he? The Staircase stays uncertain with detailed examinations and sharp focus. It’s a slow burn of tension, and Rotten Tomatoes calls it “captivating and complex.”
6. The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst
We know the big finale, but the series takes a tough look at wealth, power, and murder. Rotten Tomatoes finds it both intense and very engaging.
5. The Keepers
A nun’s death, silenced stories, and a divided community—The Keepers mixes smart investigation with deep emotions. Critics on Rotten Tomatoes describe it as haunting, stirring, and unforgettable.
4. I’ll Be Gone in the Dark
Michelle McNamara’s pursuit of the Golden State Killer becomes a story of its own. This series is deep, moving, and powerful—Rotten Tomatoes ranks its true emotions highly.
3. The Innocence Files
True-crime with a purpose: examining wrongful convictions and the tough efforts of the Innocence Project. Sober, truthful, and hopeful. Rotten Tomatoes highly recommends it, with a perfect score.
2. Seduced: Inside the NXIVM Cult
A personal view on deception, control, and survival within NXIVM. Seduced is both a warning and a story of resilience, and Rotten Tomatoes finds it captivating and hard to miss.
1. The Lady and the Dale
Liz Carmichael’s rise and fall—with a failed car scheme and major trouble—proves truth is stranger than fiction. A blend of old footage, animation, and major discussions makes it a top choice on Rotten Tomatoes as thrilling and essential.
Plan your weekend—it’s set to be wild. These 15 true-crime shows are intense, thought-provoking, and very addictive. Ready for the binge?