15 Small-Town Mysteries to Stream Now

Share This Post

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

There’s a certain appeal to cozy crime shows that’s hard to resist. They lure you in with clever, well-crafted mysteries, inviting settings, and characters that are like long-lost pals. The action may be serious, but the atmosphere remains comforting—picture idyllic beachside communities, quaint European neighborhoods, or small towns where everyone knows each other (and everyone has a secret). When you’re in the mood for some suspenseful fun that isn’t quite so dark, these 15 cozy crime and small-town mystery series hit the spot just right.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

15. The Mallorca Files

With the beautiful island of Mallorca as the backdrop, this fun and light-hearted British crime series follows by-the-book detective Miranda Blake as she partners with her easy-going German counterpart, Max Winter, to solve crimes ranging from art theft to cold-blooded murder.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

The true magic of the series, however, is found in the relationship between its two leads. Miranda’s by-the-book approach is the perfect foil for Max’s easygoing, go-with-the-flow mentality. As the series progresses, so does the warmth at its center. Throw in self-contained cases, stunning scenery, and an effortless, escapist quality, and The Mallorca Files becomes the type of cozy crime drama that feels like a vacation in the sun, with a dash of mystery thrown in for good measure.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

14. Monk

At the center of this beloved detective series is Tony Shalhoub’s iconic portrayal of Adrian Monk. A former elite homicide detective, Monk has a genius-level mind for solving crimes—but he also has crippling phobias and obsessive-compulsive disorder, which make his life difficult and also make him a brilliant detective.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Although this series is full of clever and witty humor, it never treats Monk’s suffering with levity. Monk’s loss and struggles with mental health issues are treated with a sincere care that gives the series a depth of emotion that will surprise you. With a warm and lovable cast of characters and well-structured mysteries, Monk is a series that combines wit, warmth, and clever storytelling.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

13. The Madame Blanc Mysteries

After her husband’s sudden death, antiques expert Jean White relocates to a picturesque French village and soon finds herself assisting local police with baffling murders. Her deep knowledge of antiques and art history becomes an unlikely crime-solving tool.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

The series thrives on its warm village atmosphere, colorful locals, and gentle pacing. With elegant clues and minimal violence, The Madame Blanc Mysteries is ideal for viewers who prefer clever deductions and cozy European charm over gritty realism.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

12. Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators

In Stratford-upon-Avon, unlikely partners Frank Hathaway and Luella Shakespeare run a small PI agency tackling everything from disappearances to murder. Their contrasting personalities drive both the humor and emotional growth of the show.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

The theatrical town setting adds flair, while the mysteries themselves stick to classic whodunit roots. Lighthearted, character-focused, and rich in local color, this series is comfort viewing at its finest.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

11. Psych

This energetic mystery-comedy follows Shawn Spencer, a hyper-observant goofball who convinces the police he’s psychic. Alongside his best friend Gus, he solves crimes through sharp deduction and a whole lot of nonsense.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Packed with pop-culture jokes, fast banter, and genuine emotional beats, Psych never forgets to deliver a solid mystery beneath the laughs. The deep friendship at its center gives the show lasting warmth and charm.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

10. McDonald & Dodds

Set in the historic city of Bath, this British series teams driven DCI Lauren McDonald with quietly brilliant DS Dodds. While McDonald brings ambition and energy, Dodds often cracks the case with unexpected insight.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

The show leans into traditional mystery storytelling, rewarding patient viewers with thoughtful twists. Its stately setting, understated humor, and character-driven plots make it a cozy standout.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

9. Harry Wild

Jane Seymour stars as Harriet “Harry” Wild, a retired literature professor who can’t resist getting involved in police investigations in Dublin. Teaming up with street-smart teen Fergus, she solves crimes with literary flair and sharp intuition.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

The show’s warmth comes from its unlikely duo and Harry’s fearless personality. Dublin’s lively atmosphere and clever storytelling give each mystery a fresh, engaging feel.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

8. Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries

This serene seaside series follows former detective Jeff Jackson as he investigates crimes on Martha’s Vineyard alongside local doctor Zee Madeiras. The coastal scenery sets a peaceful tone that contrasts gently with the murders at hand.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Each case unfolds at a relaxed pace, focusing on character relationships and clean storytelling. With minimal violence and plenty of heart, it’s ideal for fans of classic, comforting mysteries.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

7. Poirot

David Suchet’s definitive portrayal of Hercule Poirot brings Agatha Christie’s iconic detective to life. Armed with his “little grey cells,” Poirot unravels intricate crimes across lavish estates, luxury trains, and glamorous European locales.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Every episode delivers a complete mystery, building methodically toward a satisfying reveal. Stylish, clever, and endlessly elegant, Poirot remains a gold standard for cozy crime television.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

6. Hawaii Five-0

While more action-packed than most cozy mysteries, Hawaii Five-0 earns its spot thanks to its strong sense of place and character camaraderie. Set in Hawaii, the series follows an elite task force tackling high-stakes crimes.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Sun-soaked scenery, playful banter, and strong team dynamics soften the intensity. For viewers who like their mysteries with a bit more momentum, this series offers a balanced mix of thrills and heart.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

5. Midsomer Murders

This long-running British favorite is set in idyllic villages where murder seems oddly frequent. Each episode features elaborate plots, eccentric suspects, and a calm, methodical investigation led by DCI Barnaby.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Despite the body count, the tone remains comforting thanks to its countryside charm and puzzle-like storytelling. It’s a perfect pick for fans who love layered mysteries wrapped in quaint settings.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

4. Resident Alien

Blending sci-fi, comedy, and mystery, Resident Alien follows an alien disguised as a small-town doctor who finds himself tangled in a murder investigation. Alan Tudyk’s performance is both hilarious and surprisingly heartfelt.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

The show balances absurd humor with thoughtful explorations of humanity, community, and belonging. Its small-town setting and unconventional approach make it a refreshingly different take on cozy crime.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

3. Longmire

Set in rural Wyoming, Longmire centers on a widowed sheriff navigating crime, politics, and personal loss in a tight-knit community. The series blends Western aesthetics with layered mystery storytelling.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Its emotional depth and strong sense of place elevate the procedural elements. Even viewers who don’t usually gravitate toward crime dramas often find themselves hooked by its grounded, character-driven approach.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

2. Miss Scarlet and the Duke

This Victorian-era mystery follows Eliza Scarlet, a determined woman carrying on her late father’s detective agency. With help from her police ally, The Duke, she navigates crime-solving in a male-dominated world.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Witty dialogue, slow-burn chemistry, and period detail drive the show as much as the mysteries themselves. It’s a smart, stylish series that blends historical charm with modern storytelling sensibilities.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

1. High Potential

At the top of the list is this Hulu original starring Kaitlin Olson as Morgan, a single mom whose exceptional intelligence lands her a consulting role for the LAPD. Her unconventional background brings a fresh lens to crime-solving.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

The show balances sharp humor, family dynamics, and smart mysteries with ease. Relatable, fast-paced, and full of heart, High Potential feels like a modern cozy crime hit in the making.

Image Source: Bing Image. License: All Creative Commons

Cozy crime shows prove that mysteries don’t have to be dark to be compelling. With memorable characters, inviting settings, and clever storytelling, these series offer the perfect escape for viewers who love puzzles with personality. Whether you’re in the mood for a seaside sleuth or a small-town secret, there’s something here to curl up with next. 

Related Posts

10 Indie Masterpieces Featuring Unforgettable Performances

Indie movies have long been a launching pad for...

9 Stars Who Trained as Dancers Before Conquering the Big Screen

Let’s face it: going from dancing in clubs or...

30 Famous Couples Who Proved Hollywood Wrong

In Hollywood, relationships can appear to be momentary—shining brightly...

15 Times Stars Walked Away from Major Movies

Hollywood is full of “what if” moments, roles that...

Top 10 Celebrity Eyes You Can’t Look Away From

There’s something inherently mesmerizing about certain eyes, those that...

10 Majestic Movies About Monarchs and Royal Intrigue

Kings and queens have always had a magnetic pull...