We all know it: one of the great film experiences is finding a hidden gem that makes you say, “How come this isn’t more popular?” So it could be a box office flop that was actually much better than people thought, a lost film, or a movie that slipped through the cracks because of bad marketing or timing. Sleeper movies are the goodies of cinephiles. These 15 films are the perfect answer if you want to take a break from the blockbuster treadmill and add them to your must-watch list.
15. Crooklyn (1994)
Spike Lee enthusiasts will know this one, but everyone else typically doesn’t. Crooklyn is a semi-autobiographical coming-of-age slice-of-life of a Black middle-class Brooklyn family in the 1970s. It captures the energy of youth, the affection of siblings, and the agony of loss, all mixed with Lee’s signature humor and heart. It’s both comforting and heartbreaking, typically simultaneously.
14. The Iron Giant (1999)
Half Cold War fable, half sentimental coming-of-age tale, Brad Bird’s The Iron Giant was a box office failure but was later embraced by its supporters. An animated classic based on a boy who befriends a colossal alien robot, it’s a balancing act of warmth, wonder, and melancholy. Today, it’s rightly one of the best of its kind.
13. Devil in a Blue Dress (1995)
Denzel Washington as a detective in post-war L.A.? Yes indeed. This hip noir finds him cracking a case that’s all politics, race, and corruption. While it didn’t catch on at the box office, the film has since been celebrated for its sharp, efficient storytelling and Washington’s suave, charismatic lead performance.
12. Wait Until Dark (1967)
Audrey Hepburn is perhaps best known for Breakfast at Tiffany’s, but what she does in this is something different. Playing a blind woman who has to deal with violent intruders, Hepburn gives one of her most tense performances. The tension is expertly built, and it’s proof that Hepburn’s talents lie far beyond glitzy rom-coms.
11. Ghost Dog: The Way of the Samurai (1999)
Only Jim Jarmusch could conceive of a film about a mob-employed hitman who adheres to samurai codes. Forest Whitaker is compelling as the title character, bringing stillness and depth to an unorthodox, poetic crime drama. Half gangster film, half meditative essay, Ghost Dog has since become a cult favorite.
10. Paper Moon (1973)
A black-and-white road comedy from the Great Depression, this features a con man and a profane little girl who might be his daughter. Real-life siblings Ryan and Tatum O’Neal shine on screen, with Tatum winning an Oscar for her performance. It’s clever, beautiful to watch, and loaded with charm.
9. Pig (2021)
Nicolas Cage as a truffle pig tracker chasing his stolen pig in a setup for a joke, but Pig is no joke. It’s a gentle-spoken, deeply moving drama of grief, remembrance, and finding meaning. Cage’s understated, moving performance was a reminder that he’s also one of today’s most fascinating actors.
8. The Long Goodbye (1973)
Robert Altman brought a twist to the traditional detective story with Elliott Gould’s chain-smoking, wisecracking Philip Marlowe. It’s noir-ish, half-satire, and totally original. Offbeat, slyly funny, and visually inventive, it’s one of Altman’s more stylish attempts, and one of Gould’s best performances.
7. Drácula (1931, Spanish version)
Filmed at night on the same sets as Bela Lugosi’s Dracula, the Spanish-language version is, in many ways, the superior film, longer, moodier, and technically more ambitious. Featuring Latino actors in roles that avoided stereotypes, it pushed boundaries at the time but was largely forgotten for decades. Today, it’s a revelation.
6. Rachel Getting Married (2007)
Anne Hathaway lost the rom-com persona with this untrammeled performance of a recovering addict returning home for her sister’s wedding. Handheld camerawork makes it documentary-intimate, and family dynamics are painfully real. Hathaway, Rosemarie DeWitt, and Debra Winger all deliver career-best performances.
5. Planet of the Vampires (1965)
This Italian sci-fi horror movie reads like pulp, but is aesthetically stunning and eerily influential. Space explorers who go on an alien world fall prey to an evil entity in a story clearly ripped from Alien. From its gothic production style to its creepy atmosphere, it’s a must-watch for science fiction horror fans.
4. Crooklyn (1994)
Yes, it’s on here again, because it truly is that underrated. Spike Lee’s retro, bittersweet tribute to his Brooklyn boyhood deserves twice the love. If you haven’t seen it yet, move it to the top of your queue.
3. Something Good – Negro Kiss (1898)
Not a scene, but a work of sublime cinema history. This short clip of two Black actors kissing is one of the earliest known films to depict Black love positively, a dramatic turnabout from the racist caricatures of its time. Rediscovered over a hundred years later, it’s as lively as it is innovative.
2. Lost in America (1985)
Albert Brooks skewers the American Dream with this wicked satire of a couple who give up everything to attain freedom on the open road. Hilarious and nasty, it’s a reminder that Brooks was one of the sharpest comedic voices of his generation, and still woefully underappreciated.
1. Within Our Gates (1920)
Oscar Micheaux directed this silent film is the oldest known feature that was directed by a Black filmmaker. Brawling racism, violence, and injustice head-on, it was so incendiary for its time that it was banned in most places. Found decades later, it remains a cornerstone of American film history.
The next time you’re endlessly scrolling, skip the usual blockbusters and give one of these overlooked treasures a chance. From forgotten noirs to groundbreaking indies, these films prove that sometimes the best stories are the ones hiding in the shadows.