Other times, the greatest soap operas on TV aren’t what the audience sees on screen—but what happens behind the scenes. Bitter egos, horrid behavior, or legal scandals will kill a dream role. Forget shock twists in the script—these exits were driven by behind-the-scenes chaos. Here’s a countdown of the most notorious actor-driven deaths.
10. Jon Polito – Homicide: Life on the Street (Steve Crosetti)
Polito protested about his blunders over changes to the show—and suffered. His detective character was found dead, a suicide, in the bay. Years later, Polito admitted he’d been wrong, but by then the storyline was set.
9. Dominic Monaghan – Lost (Charlie Pace)
Monaghan became disenchanted with working and didn’t hesitate to share his disdain with co-star Matthew Fox. Perhaps it was personal issues or artistic burnout, but the result was Charlie’s drowning death scene—a farewell that seemed to calm actor and crew alike.
8. Michael Pitt – Boardwalk Empire (Jimmy Darmody)
Talented but volatile, Pitt acquired a reputation as an impossible person to work with—showing up late, forgetting his lines, and brawling in fistfights on location. The on-screen killing off of his character was as ruthless as the behind-the-scenes decision to cut him loose. Even his agent dumped him after that.
7. Mischa Barton – The O.C. (Marissa Cooper)
Marissa’s car crash exit was no accident. Backstage, Barton’s rough partying and developing diva image created production problems. She would later admit that her life was getting out of hand at the time—making her on-screen death seem almost inevitable.
6. Columbus Short – Scandal (Harrison Wright)
Shonda Rhimes is notoriously devoted to her actors—but even she has boundaries. Short’s personal scandals and legal issues made him a liability. His character was disposed of in a hail, and the actor was shortly thereafter heading into rehab.
5. Taylor Momsen – Gossip Girl (Jenny Humphrey)
Once a mainstay, Momsen’s unstable attitude and inattention on set resulted in her being written out. Even fashion legend Tim Gunn criticized her as “a pathetic diva.” By the time Jenny Humphrey had left, nobody was surprised.
4. Nicollette Sheridan – Desperate Housewives (Edie Britt)
Dressingly, clashes with show creator Marc Cherry and allegations of professional misconduct derailed Sheridan’s tenure. Edie Britt’s melodramatic death—electrocution and subsequent car accident—was no more melodramatic than the character. Sheridan’s wrongful termination lawsuit ended in a mistrial, leaving the drama unresolved.
3. Charlie Sheen – Two and a Half Men (Charlie Harper)
Few departures were more raucous—or more in-your-face—than Sheen’s. After a series of rants and public attacks on creator Chuck Lorre, Sheen was given the ax, and his character was killed off by a train. Ashton Kutcher took over, but Sheen’s meltdown made TV history.
2. John Amos – Good Times (James Evans)
Amos spoke out against his disapproval of the direction of the show, particularly the way it represented Black families. The conflicts with the producers led to his termination, and James Evans was written out. Amos confessed later that his frankness made him “disruptive”—a reputation that followed him.
1. Shannen Doherty – Charmed & Beverly Hills, 90210
The quintessential case study in off-screen melodrama, Doherty fought with co-stars, arrived late to set, and developed a reputation as difficult to work with. On Charmed, Prue was murdered after struggles with Alyssa Milano. On 90210, Brenda Walsh just vanished. Doherty has since mused that her volatile personality—something she attributed to early mentor Michael Landon—occasionally didn’t serve her. Nevertheless, her soap opera endings are the stuff of TV lore.
When performers push too hard, collide with directors, or allow personal soap opera to spill onto the set, the consequences are deadly—at least for their characters. Such departures remind us that at times, the actual drama is not written… it is earned.