Though Hollywood is a dream factory, it only takes one poorly performing film to shatter that dream. A disappointing film for some actors is just a challenge that they will overcome, while for others it is a signal that their career is going downhill. Theoretically, these 10 films, which range from over-hyped blockbusters to the stars making baffling career choices, caused such a drastic decline in the actors’ careers that they didn’t recover in some cases, and in others, they didn’t return at all.
10. Taylor Kitsch – John Carter
Since Friday Night Lights, Taylor Kitsch was set for superstardom—then Disney’s John Carter, a science-fiction blockbuster with a budget exceeding $250 million. Rather than starting a megabillion-dollar franchise, it flopped big time, costing the studio hundreds of millions. Kitsch took the fall, going from “next big thing” to TV and secondary roles. He’s still here, but his chance at superstardom went up in smoke on Mars.
9. Lindsay Lohan – I Know Who Killed Me
Lindsay Lohan was a teen queen-turned-tabloid fodder, and I Know Who Killed Me was her breaking point on film. The film was a disaster—convoluted plot, stilted execution—and her acting landed her several Razzies. Once a reliable star, Lohan was struggling to get good roles. Although she’s been attempting a comeback, this debacle is still a mark she’s never fully erased.
8. Halle Berry – Catwoman
Still basking in the glow of her Oscar victory, Halle Berry boarded Catwoman, one of the most notorious comic book flops of all time. Campy script, incoherent plot, and a leather bodysuit that became a joke—none of it struck gold. Berry’s career never really got back into high gear, and though she remained visible, top-notch roles grew much rarer after this debacle.
7. Sharon Stone – Basic Instinct 2
The original Basic Instinct turned Sharon Stone into a superstar. Its sequel did just the opposite. Basic Instinct 2 was unnecessary, uninspired, and unwanted. The film tanked miserably, taking away what little star power Stone had left and forcing her to scrounge for smaller roles. For all her undeniable talent, her A-list status never came back.
6. Jaden Smith – After Earth
As Will Smith’s son, Jaden was set to continue the family tradition. Sadly, After Earth was a cinematic crash and burn. Critics panned stiff dialogue and Jaden’s acting, and the box office returns rendered it a dead issue. Jaden has moved on to music and fashion, but his potential to be a top actor ended here.
5. Alicia Silverstone – Batman & Robin
Hot off the success of Clueless, Alicia Silverstone was Hollywood’s darling. Then there was Batman & Robin. The camp trainwreck is notorious for its ice puns and bat-nipples, and Silverstone’s Batgirl turn brought her nothing but scorn and a Razzie. Though she still acts, her days as a leading lady never came back.
4. Geena Davis – Cutthroat Island
After being an Oscar winner and box office attraction, Geena Davis bet on Cutthroat Island, a pirate film that capsized quickly than its vessels. With a budget-breaking price tag and disastrous losses, the film is regularly ranked among Hollywood’s most explosive bombs. Davis’s cachet nose-dived, and though she’s admired, her career never regained its height.
3. Jamie Kennedy – Son of the Mask
The Mask was a comedy classic. Son of the Mask? A nightmare that ended a career. Jamie Kennedy starred in the sequel that no one wanted, and the movie that resulted was one that was ridiculed for its cringeworthy gags and flat energy. Kennedy never once secured anything remotely like a big Hollywood part after that, spending most of his career in supporting roles thereafter.
2. Mike Myers – The Love Guru
Mike Myers was a comedy king once, with blockbusters like Austin Powers and Shrek. But The Love Guru was a monstrous flop, packed with groan-inducing jokes and stereotypes that failed to take hold. Fans and critics turned on him, and his once smoking hot career imploded. He’s popped up here and there since then, but he never regained his top status.
1. Elizabeth Berkley – Showgirls
Few career falters are as legendary as Elizabeth Berkley’s. Following Saved by the Bell, Showgirls was meant to be her crossover into a life of stardom. Instead, it became a mythic bomb, ridiculed for its over-the-top melodrama. Berkley’s career never recovered, and she was a cautionary example of how one bad risk can destroy everything.
In Hollywood, your stock is never higher than your previous hit. For these actors, it took just one film to take down careers that had otherwise been unstoppable. Some had minor comebacks, others vanished completely—but all of them remind us how cruel the business can be when the box office does.